🔗 Share this article

In my role as reviewer, I've made enough mistakes to enjoy a sense of validation when a verdict is vindicated. In the early 80s, I enthusiastically reported about a new Stephen Sondheim musical that I had seen during early showings in NYC. Panned by professional reviewers and rejected by theatergoers, the show ended shortly after its premiere. Jump ahead to recent years, the very same musical completed a twelve-month Broadway run, won four Tony awards and received glowing reviews.

The Evolution of a Masterpiece

Although I mention "the production being unchanged, the statement requires qualification. Adapted from a Depression-era work by the celebrated theatrical partnership, it continues to be the identical narrative unfolding from end to beginning. The plot examines failing friendships centering around an ambitious musician and movie producer called Franklin Shepard. During the performance, he looks back across his years and observes how time has eroded his professional relationship with playwright Charley along with their shared bond with writer Mary.

Production Changes

Following the production's failure during the early 80s, the creative team implemented significant revisions. It doesn't begin with a youthful melody composed by the protagonist but opens instead with an extravagant celebration honoring his most recent movie success. The approach to casting underwent transformation. The original 1981 cast consisted of fresh-faced performers who initially acted middle age characters and progressed seamlessly toward younger versions throughout the performance. Current productions now standardly cast mature actors who straddle the years using subtle changes.

The strength of the storytelling rests in its capacity to resonate differently with each individual. Similar to regressive narrative structures, the performance reveals how life inevitably involves negotiations, adaptations and a sense of loss.

Sondheim's Creative Genius

This exceptional production features Sondheim discreetly settling scores against his detractors. There's a delightful moment where a show business veteran admonishes the youthful main characters concerning the need to provide hummable melodies in musical productions, adding the memorable line: "I will inform you once Stravinsky achieves success." The greatest contradiction lies in the fact that Merrily We Roll Along genuinely includes multiple cherished compositions including Old Friends, Good Thing Going plus the main theme that have become lasting earworms among loyal fans.

Character Interpretation

If there exists a reasonable objection regarding the musical, it involves the central figure Franklin failing to engage emotionally. Yet, in this production, the principal actor thoughtfully represents him not as a narcissistic villain but rather as a tragic innocent who travels life's path repeatedly picking the simplest solution. The ensemble performers excellently embody the protagonist's unsatisfied emotional desires, while the most eye-catching performance comes from the actor embodying Charley, who provides the role both nervous tension and fervent faith in art's power to enhance existence.

Continuing Influence

Whether Merrily itself achieves this transformation stays with viewers to subjectively judge. The current production remains a constant joy and clearly demonstrates specifically what made a famous flop become an undeniable success. The filmed performance of this acclaimed staging offers audiences the opportunity to enjoy this remarkable transformation for themselves.